Rated 5 out of 5 by Tiffany Best eyeliner EVER!
This is the best eyeliner ever for me! I've used MANY in the past and they all run. I don't know what it is. They say they are waterproof but for some reason they all run on me except for the Marc Jacobs highliner. I love this eyeliner and will never use anything else.
Rated 5 out of 5 by JayKay But the Highliner!
If you like to wear eyeliner, buy this product. It is the smoothest, easiest application I've ever experienced in an eyeliner. And in spite of it's creamy texture, it stays put during the day. I've never used an eyeliner I like as well as this, and at age 61, that's saying a lot! The only drawback for me is that the dark brown color (my preference) contains gold sparkles. I would prefer a dark brown choice that does not include sparkles.
Rated 2 out of 5 by Shell Eye Liner
I was not happy that it smeared and I had to break a piece off before each use to get it to glide on.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Salberg7 Highliner Gel Pencils
I am an eyeliner freak and have tried all of them from high end to drugstore. These pencils are great, easy to apply, no pull, and literally do stay all day. The color selection is also very comprehensive. I have been waiting for them to be restocked - seems like it took forever! I do not see "Nice" in the selection, was it dropped? That and Jazzberry were my next choices, as well as the Navy. And Blacquer of course!